A family walking through a field at sunset

Grain Farmers Shouldn’t Shy Away from Benchmarking

January 10, 2019

Grain Farmers Shouldn’t Shy Away from Benchmarking

Minute Read

MNP’s Peter Manness talks about how benchmarking is not as much a ranking tool as it is a method to help evaluate and direct business decisions.

Peter Manness
Peter Manness
Farm Management Consultant

​​By Peter Manness, MNP

When ever I bring up benchmarking with grain farm clients, I generally get two reactions. The first is from a group of producers that immediately buy into the idea and want to know how they compare to other farms. The other group either think they are already equal to their neighbors or they don’t want to find out. Most farmers will spend all day and night talking, reading, and even tweeting about farming to anyone and everyone but they are also fiercely independent business people and don’t like to talk about the financial health of their business. The usefulness of a benchmark is not as much a ranking tool as it is a method to help evaluate and direct business decisions. I like to breakdown into three main areas; Profit, Trend and Focus.

1. Profit

I don’t like to say it’s all about the money but in business it is generally a good place to start. Whenever I look at a financial statement, I always start at the bottom of the income statement with the profit line. A benchmark can take out the markets, weather and size and show the impact of effort and management on a per unit basis (per acre for grain farms). Are we generating a reasonable profit for the size of our operation on a per unit basis. If not, why? And secondly, does it matter? The only two things we must give are time and money. If our efforts do not generate a return, then over the long run, are we making good use of our time? It is okay to give up some profits to devote your time elsewhere, but how can we make an informed decision if we don’t know what we are giving up? There is often a concern among producers that one region is way more profitable than other regions and farms can’t be compared across broad geographical areas. In our Manitoba region, our most recent grain benchmark numbers showed that the top 15 producers were spread over 10 crop insurance risk areas, indicating to me strong management is just as, if not more valuable than good land.​

2. Trend

What trend you are on is just as important as where you are. This is one of the greatest benefits of using benchmark data versus historical averages or targets. In Western Canada, producers have maintained profits by not only expanding acres but by continually pushing yields higher. The current trend is adding 1 bu per acre per year in wheat yield and over ½ bu per acre in Canola. We obviously know that costs are rising along with the increase in yield. If we understand how our trend compares to the benchmark trend, it helps us to see if we are keeping up on a revenue basis and managing our costs. A five-year historical average on machinery costs is useful but you can’t buy a new combine for the same price as in 2013. This needs to be taken into consideration. Trend also gives us hope if some costs are out of line. If we can hold them in the short term, it may bring us back into line with the benchmark over time.

3. Focus

Focus is the final piece after you understand how you compare from a profit standpoint and the trend you are on. A farm financial statement is full of numbers and it is easy to get caught up focusing on something that isn’t important. If you aren’t hitting the profit target, then you can go back to see where the problem might be. Are we short on revenue? Do we spend too much on inputs versus what we get in return? Is it costing us too much in operating costs or overhead? It might not lead to an easy solution, but at minimum it will give you more certainty in how you deploy your management skills. If you are one of the most profitable producers, does it change your perspective on how you approach growth?​​

Farmers are all trying to play the same game but ultimately no two farms or farmers are exactly alike. By utilizing benchmark information, you can see what things make your farm successful, how you can continue to achieve that in the future and what areas to focus on to make it happen.

Peter Manness, PAg, is a Business Advisor in MNP’s Farm Management Consulting group. He can be reached at 204.727.0661 or [email protected].

The Rubik's Cube is still a very popular puzzle toy. The fact is that it's even more popular than in the 80's.


  • Confidence
    Holding a portfolio on one hand, comparing data on another

    July 28, 2021

    How to optimize value from an Internal Audit co-sourcing partnership

    Co-sourcing your internal audit function can help you navigate several contemporary challenges — including the need for greater agility and subject matter expertise, as well as cost and resourcing pressures. Here we investigate practical steps to find the right vendor and make this relationship as seamless, targeted, and cost effective as possible.

  • Progress
    person reviewing graphs on their phone

    July 26, 2021

    Automating finance, so you can focus on your business

    Cloud accounting and bookkeeping solutions allow you to focus on the critical parts of your business instead of shuffling through paperwork every week.

  • Progress

    July 22, 2021

    Cloud accounting and bookkeeping can transform your real estate and construction operations

    Priorities are changing after the long hours that came with navigating COVID-19. Here’s how you can free up time to focus on what really matters.