people discussing business interruption insurance claims

Case Study: Business Interruption Insurance Claim

March 16, 2022

Case Study: Business Interruption Insurance Claim

3 Minute Read

When a privately owned high-end furniture store experienced an insurance loss while they were on track to double their annual growth, they approached MNP to help quantify the losses.

Ontario Insurance Advisory Lead

The Project

The COVID-19 pandemic has brought seismic changes to the retail space; some businesses struggled mightily while others saw an increase in demand. Home furnishing stores saw large increases in business as consumers began spending more money on home improvements rather than vacations, dining, or events.

When a privately owned high-end furniture store experienced an insurance loss while they were on track to double their annual growth, they approached MNP to help quantify the losses. How do you factor in such growth when making a claim?

maze icon The challenge

Insurance companies can be conservative institutions. Seeing a period of growth that’s out of the ordinary, they may treat it as an outlier rather than a predictor of future success.

Our client was experiencing nearly 100 percent year-over-year growth figures when they had an insurance event. The insurance company, being conservative as it is, didn’t believe the upward trend would continue.

light bulb icon The Solution

After taking care of the immediate need for repairs, the furniture company turned its attention towards calculating its losses due to the business interruption. Insurance companies consider several factors including how long the interruption was, how much revenue was lost (and what expenses were reduced) by pausing operations, and how much the company could have earned had the event not occurred.

Our team presented figures to the insurer that were aggressive but evidence-based, which showed that this interruption during a time of such strong growth should result in a large loss amount. We were able to lay out multiple different scenarios showing how the historical results confirmed our initial trending analysis, even though it appeared aggressive to the insurer.

checkmark icon The Outcome

By showing the results of what occurred after repairs, along with the trending leading into the loss period, we were able to show the insurance company proof our aggressive figures were accurate. They offered a settlement figure over 60 percent higher than their first offer.

Businesses aren’t cookie cutter. Neither is their insurance coverage. MNP’s Insurance Advisory team provides thorough analysis, insightful reporting and credible testimony which will help you resolve claims with confidence. We also work with you to ensure you have the appropriate coverage and your insurer treats you fairly.

Contact us

To learn more about how MNP can help your organization, contact Stephen Dodd, MBA, CPA, CMA, Ontario Insurance Advisory Lead


  • Confidence

    September 27, 2022

    Budget 2022 Tax Measures Impacting Financial Institutions and Credit Unions

    Uncertain about whether tax measures in the 2022 Federal Budget will impact credit unions? Here’s what we’ve learned.

  • Confidence

    September 21, 2022

    Get what you want – what you really, really want - from your business

    Knowing what you need and what your options are is difficult to do on your own and often the reason business owners fail to plain for their own exit.

  • Progress

    September 16, 2022

    Looking beyond tax — planning for the use and ownership of the family vacation property

    Owning and managing a family vacation property between generations requires you to consider more than just the tax questions.