Financing the family farm for the future

How to manage equity

Once you have reached the right amount of debt for your farm, the remainder of your capital structure needs are composed of some form of equity. The most common forms of equity are:

Common shares

• Partial ownership of the farm
• Have voting rights
• Participate in profits through dividends and capital gains

Preferred shares

• Partial ownership of the farm – fixed to a set amount
• Priority claim to dividends and redemption
• Generally, no voting rights

Shareholder loans (has characteristics of debt but acts more like equity)

• No ownership in the farm
• No voting rights
• May be interest bearing
• Repayable on demand

Knowing which form of equity is right for your farm is dependant on the owners and their objectives. If all owners’ interests are aligned to grow the farm and there is no need for liquidity, then common shares would be the best choice.

However, it is rare for stakeholders to never need liquidity from their investment. Liquidity events could include paying for personal expenses or assets, redeploying capital into a different business, or equalizing estates when farms transition between generations or experience family breakups. Incorporating characteristics of liquidity, like dividends or redemption features into equity instruments, becomes more important in these situations.

Another consideration is differentiating between ownership and operations when it comes to family involvement. If families want to keep the farm going at its current size, it’s important to address the future capital structure because increased debt from a conventional bank may not be enough to facilitate this.

Some examples of how to keep the farm together while providing for non-farming owners include:

• Land owned by non-farming family with rights of first refusal and long-term leases in place to ensure the farming investors can continue to farm
• Preferred shares owned by non-farming owners that provide an attractive rate of return and liquidity events
• Shareholder loans that pay a reasonable rate of interest and have ability to obtain liquidity at agreed times to non-farming owners

The key to accessing ever-increasing capital for your farm may come down to attracting equity differently. Structuring an equity instrument held by non-farming family members may convince them that being an investor in the farm is preferred to other investment opportunities.

Quasi-equity alternatives

In addition to the equity alternatives discussed, here are some you may not have considered:

• Strategic partners: A recent trend for farms to continue to grow that involves the use of joint ventures or partnerships. The objective in entering into these types of arrangements with other farms is to access opportunities to ensure fixed costs are amortized over increased acres. The economies of scale of larger farms acting together can reduce risk and enable you to capitalize on bigger and more strategic opportunities.
• Financial partners: Entities like AreaOne and pension funds are becoming more prevalent in farmland ownership. Entering into arrangements with entities that have no interest in farming may be a way to continue growing your farm without increasing debt or equity.
• Philanthropic partners: If the older generation still wants the family farm to stay together but there is too much value to leave any one family member or generation, consider setting up a private foundation to hold land. This will provide future generations the ability to continue farming without leaving all the value to the current generation.

Attracting capital, both debt and equity, into Canada’s farming economy is critical for the health of the industry. Beyond that, your farm’s future success can be solidified with strategic and well-structured planning.

You don’t have to make all these decisions on your own. MNP’s team of agriculture experts can help you find the solution that best suits your unique needs. To learn more, contact your local advisor and visit our site.